For waffles, the best spread depends on whether you want a sweet topping, a nut-forward alternative, or a savory crunch. Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler leads for waffle-ready flavor variety, with honey roasted, butterscotch, cinnamon, and chocolate in crunchy peanut butter. Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Variety Pack is my pick for maple and oatmeal-cookie notes with a lower-carb plain option, while Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut Butter suits anyone who wants a less dessert-like, protein-rich spread.
Get baking supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The tradeoff is straightforward: sweeter flavors pair naturally with plain waffles but may not suit buyers avoiding added sweetness; plain and mixed-nut spreads offer more flexibility, yet can taste saltier or more savory than a classic waffle topping. I’ve ranked these options by how clearly their flavors and textures fit waffles, how useful their variety is, and what compromises a buyer should expect. Allergy and texture preferences matter too: these picks range from crunchy peanut butter to walnut butter and blends containing several nuts and seeds.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Nutty Novelties is the clearest choice for sweet waffles, with four crunchy peanut butter flavors including butterscotch and chocolate.
- Crazy Go Nuts offers the most distinct walnut-based lineup: sea salt, maple, and oatmeal cookie, with the plain flavor providing a less sweet counterpoint.
- Kirkland Signature combines almonds, cashews, flax, chia, and pumpkin seeds and supplies 7 grams of protein per serving, but its flavor is less dessert-focused.
- All In brings the broadest mix of nuts and seeds in a crunchy spread; its savory profile may work better with less-sweet waffles than with a syrup-heavy plate.
- For waffle use, check both texture and allergens: several products are crunchy, and the All In spread contains peanuts, almonds, and sesame.
| Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler Peanut Butter Gift Pack, 4 Flavors, 8 oz (Pack of 4) |  | Best Overall for Sweet Waffles | Flavors: Honey Roasted, Butterscotch, Cinnamon, Chocolate | Pack size: 4 jars | Jar size: 8 ounces per jar | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Variety Pack, 3-Pack |  | Best Walnut Sampler for Breakfast Flavors | Pack size: 3-pack | Flavors: Plain with sea salt, maple, oatmeal cookie | Main ingredient: California walnuts | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut Butter |  | Best Protein-Rich Everyday Blend | Ingredients: Almonds, cashews, flax seeds, chia seeds, pumpkin seeds | Protein: 7 grams per serving | Product type: Mixed nut and seed butter | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| All In Mixed Nut and Seed Butter, 8 oz |  | Best Crunchy Savory Blend | Net weight: 8 oz | Highlighted ingredients: Peanuts, almonds, sunflower, pumpkin, flax, hemp, chia, and sesame seeds | Texture: Crunchy | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| nutbutter sampler for waffle | Flavors | Pack size | Texture | Dietary attributes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler | Honey Roasted, Butterscotch, Cinnamon, Chocolate | 4 jars | Crunchy | Non-GMO; gluten-free |
| Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Va | Plain with sea salt, maple, oatmeal cookie | 3-pack | — | Vegan, keto, low carb, gluten-free |
| Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut B | — | — | — | — |
| All In Mixed Nut and Seed Butt | — | — | Crunchy | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler Peanut Butter Gift Pack, 4 Flavors, 8 oz (Pack of 4)
When the goal is to make plain waffles taste like four different breakfasts, Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler is the most direct match in this group. Its four crunchy peanut butter flavors—honey roasted, butterscotch, cinnamon, and chocolate—give buyers more sweet directions to try than the three-flavor walnut pack from Crazy Go Nuts. That range matters on waffles: cinnamon can complement fruit, chocolate leans dessert-like, and butterscotch or honey roasted can add sweetness without relying on a plain spread.
The main distinction is its crunchy peanut butter base. It adds bite rather than a smooth, uniform layer, which can be welcome on a soft waffle but may feel too coarse for someone who wants a thin, even spread. The product is described as made without preservatives, additives, or fillers, and as non-GMO and gluten-free. It also has little added sugar, but the flavors are still explicitly sweet; buyers seeking a truly unsweetened topping may prefer Crazy Go Nuts’ plain sea-salt walnut butter or the broader, less dessert-oriented blends from Kirkland and All In.
Compared with the walnut sampler, this pack puts more emphasis on familiar sweet flavor than on a lower-carb profile. Its four jars also offer more flavor variety than the single mixed-nut spreads. I rank it first because flavor variety and waffle compatibility align especially well here, not because it is the best choice for every diet or texture preference.
Pros:- Four sweet flavors give plain waffles distinct topping options.
- Crunchy texture adds contrast to a soft waffle.
- Made without preservatives, additives, or fillers, according to the product description.
- Described as non-GMO and gluten-free, with little added sugar.
Cons:- The sweet flavor lineup is not suited to buyers seeking an unsweetened spread.
- Contains peanut butter and a crunchy texture, which may not fit some allergies or texture preferences.
Best for: Waffle fans who want several sweet, crunchy peanut butter flavors to rotate through or share.
Not ideal for: People who want unsweetened nut butter, a smooth spread, or a peanut-free option.
- Flavors:Honey Roasted, Butterscotch, Cinnamon, Chocolate
- Pack size:4 jars
- Jar size:8 ounces per jar
- Texture:Crunchy
- Dietary attributes:Non-GMO; gluten-free
- Made in:Telford, Pennsylvania
Our verdict“I’d choose this four-jar pack first for sweet waffles when flavor variety matters more than a neutral or sugar-conscious profile.”
Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Variety Pack, 3-Pack
Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Variety Pack is the strongest alternative if peanut butter is not the flavor you want on waffles. Its three California-walnut spreads cover a useful range: plain with sea salt, maple, and oatmeal cookie. Maple is the clear breakfast-minded choice, while oatmeal cookie leans treat-like; the plain jar offers a counterpoint to the sweeter flavors. Compared with Nutty Novelties, this sampler has fewer flavors and a more walnut-centered character, but it also avoids making every jar taste like a variation on sweet peanut butter.
The stated 2 net carbs per serving may appeal to buyers tracking carbohydrates, and the product is described as vegan, keto, low carb, gluten-free, and non-GMO. Those claims do not make every flavor sugar-free: the maple and oatmeal-cookie varieties contain some sugar. The plain option is not a neutral blank canvas either, since its sea-salt flavor is described as slightly salty. On a waffle, that savory edge may suit someone who likes sweet-and-salty toppings, but it can be less appealing if the plan is to add syrup as well.
This pack comes second because its flavor lineup suits breakfast while offering more dietary variety than the sweet peanut butter assortment. Its tradeoff is that walnut flavor and saltiness are more prominent than in the broadly familiar Nutty Novelties selection. Choose it for a walnut-first sampler; skip it if you want classic peanut butter taste, a fully unsweetened assortment, or a salt-free plain spread.
Pros:- Three flavors include both breakfast-friendly maple and a plain option.
- Made with California walnuts, according to the product description.
- Stated net carbs are 2 per serving.
- Described as vegan, gluten-free, and made without added colors or preservatives.
Cons:- Maple and oatmeal-cookie varieties contain some sugar.
- The plain sea-salt variety may taste too salty for some waffle toppings.
- Offers three flavors rather than Nutty Novelties’ four.
Best for: Buyers who want walnut butter on waffles, especially those looking for maple flavor and a lower-carb option.
Not ideal for: People who dislike walnuts, need every flavor to be free of added sugar, or want a mild, unsalted plain spread.
- Pack size:3-pack
- Flavors:Plain with sea salt, maple, oatmeal cookie
- Main ingredient:California walnuts
- Net carbs:2 per serving
- Dietary attributes:Vegan, keto, low carb, gluten-free
- Other claims:Non-GMO; organic walnut butter
Our verdict“I’d pick this walnut trio for a maple-forward breakfast spread and a lower-carb stated profile, while checking whether its sugar and salt suit your preferences.”
Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut Butter
Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut Butter takes a more restrained route than the flavor samplers. It combines dry-roasted almonds and cashews with flax, chia, and pumpkin seeds, so the appeal is the mix of nuts and seeds rather than a set of sweet flavors. The stated 7 grams of protein per serving gives buyers a concrete reason to choose it as part of a more filling breakfast, while its suggested uses—toast, sandwiches, and dipping—signal that it is meant to work beyond waffles.
That versatility is also the tradeoff. Nutty Novelties and Crazy Go Nuts both supply named flavors designed to create a more distinctive topping; Kirkland does not offer that kind of flavor rotation. For waffles, it makes more sense when the rest of the plate supplies sweetness through fruit or another topping, or when the buyer wants the waffle to stay a supporting part of breakfast. Its blend can bring a varied nut-and-seed profile, but the provided details do not state sweetness, salt level, or texture, so I would not choose it expecting a dessert-like spread or a particular degree of crunch.
Compared with All In, Kirkland shares the mixed-nut-and-seed idea but keeps its listed ingredients to almonds, cashews, flax, chia, and pumpkin seeds. All In adds peanuts and more seed types, including sesame, and is explicitly described as crunchy. Kirkland earns this role for its protein figure and everyday versatility, rather than waffle-specific sweetness. Choose it when a flexible blend matters more than sampler flavors; look elsewhere if you want a clearly sweet, ready-made waffle topping.
Pros:- Combines almonds, cashews, flax, chia, and pumpkin seeds.
- Provides 7 grams of protein per serving, as stated in the product details.
- Versatile for spreading, dipping, or eating on its own.
- A less dessert-focused alternative to the two flavor samplers.
Cons:- No distinct flavor assortment is listed, unlike Nutty Novelties and Crazy Go Nuts.
- The supplied details do not specify texture, sweetness, or salt level.
- Its mixed-nut profile may not satisfy buyers looking for a classic sweet waffle spread.
Best for: Buyers who want an everyday nut-and-seed spread with a stated protein amount and uses beyond waffles.
Not ideal for: Anyone shopping specifically for sweet waffle flavors, a multi-flavor sampler, or clearly specified texture and sweetness.
- Ingredients:Almonds, cashews, flax seeds, chia seeds, pumpkin seeds
- Protein:7 grams per serving
- Product type:Mixed nut and seed butter
- Suggested uses:Toast, sandwiches, fruit and vegetable dipping
- Nut base:Dry-roasted almonds and cashews
- Flavor options:No variety pack flavors listed
Our verdict“I’d choose Kirkland for a flexible, protein-containing nut-and-seed blend, not as my first pick for a sweet or flavor-varied waffle topping.”
All In Mixed Nut and Seed Butter, 8 oz
All In Mixed Nut and Seed Butter is the most ingredient-dense choice here: roasted peanuts and almonds are blended with sunflower, pumpkin, flax, hemp, chia, and sesame seeds. Its explicitly crunchy texture gives waffles a clear contrast, especially if they are served with fruit or kept less sweet. Unlike Nutty Novelties’ four sweet peanut butter flavors or Crazy Go Nuts’ maple and oatmeal-cookie jars, All In is a single savory-leaning spread rather than a dessert-style sampler.
The stated absence of artificial thickeners, stabilizers, and hydrogenated oils will matter to some ingredient-focused buyers, and the spread is also presented as suitable for toast, oatmeal, smoothies, dips, and baking. That breadth can make one jar useful across breakfast and cooking, but it does not replace the choice offered by a multi-jar pack. Sea salt and sesame oil contribute to the flavor profile, so a buyer expecting a sweet, mild waffle topping may find this a poor match. Nutty Novelties is the better pick for sweeter plates; Kirkland is the closer comparison if you want a mixed-nut blend, though its supplied ingredient list is shorter and its texture is not specified.
I place All In fourth because its appeal is more about crunchy variety and broad kitchen use than a direct fit for sweet waffles. It is not a weak option; it simply serves a narrower waffle preference. Check the allergen list carefully: it contains peanuts, almonds, and sesame, alongside several seeds. Choose it when savory crunch is welcome and the ingredient mix works for your household, not when you need an allergy-conscious or dessert-like sampler.
Pros:- Combines peanuts, almonds, and six kinds of seeds.
- Crunchy texture adds bite to waffles and other foods.
- Can be used on toast, in oatmeal or smoothies, as a dip, or in baking.
- Made without artificial thickeners, stabilizers, or hydrogenated oils, as described.
Cons:- Savory flavor may not suit buyers seeking sweet waffle toppings.
- Contains peanuts, almonds, and sesame.
- Single 8-ounce product rather than a multi-flavor sampler.
Best for: People who like crunchy, savory nut-and-seed toppings and want one spread for waffles, oatmeal, smoothies, and baking.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer sweet spreads, need a peanut-, almond-, or sesame-free product, or want multiple flavors in one pack.
- Net weight:8 oz
- Highlighted ingredients:Peanuts, almonds, sunflower, pumpkin, flax, hemp, chia, and sesame seeds
- Texture:Crunchy
- Contains:Sesame oil and sea salt
- Artificial thickeners:None, according to the product description
- Stabilizers:None, according to the product description
- Hydrogenated oils:None, according to the product description
Our verdict“I’d choose All In for crunchy, savory versatility, but would favor Nutty Novelties or Crazy Go Nuts for sweeter waffle-focused flavor choices.”
How We Picked
I compared these four options as waffle toppings, not as interchangeable jars of nut butter. I gave more weight to whether the stated flavors work with a sweet breakfast, whether the texture adds something useful to a waffle, and whether a variety pack helps buyers find a preferred topping. A flavor sampler has an advantage when it can change the character of a plain waffle; a less sweet blend can be the stronger choice for someone who wants flexibility or a more savory finish.
I also considered ingredient and dietary details supplied for each product, including walnut or peanut bases, seed blends, stated net carbs, and protein. Those facts help distinguish the options but do not establish that a product meets an individual diet or allergy need. The descriptions do not provide comparable serving sizes, sugar quantities, or spreadability details across the lineup, so I avoid treating those as directly measured differences.
The ranking reflects each option’s specific role. Nutty Novelties comes first because its four explicitly sweet flavors most directly answer the waffle-topping brief. Crazy Go Nuts follows for a more distinctive walnut sampler and a maple flavor that suits breakfast, though two flavors contain some sugar and the sea-salt variety is not sweet. Kirkland earns a place for its balanced nut-and-seed mix and stated protein content, while All In is best for people who want a crunchy, savory blend with varied seeds. Waffle fit, choice, and tradeoffs drive the order; no single spread is right for every palate.
| nutbutter sampler for waffle | Flavors | Dietary attributes |
|---|---|---|
| Nutty Novelties Sweet Sampler | Honey Roasted, Butterscotch, Cinnamon, Chocolate | Non-GMO; gluten-free |
| Crazy Go Nuts Walnut Butter Va | Plain with sea salt, maple, oatmeal cookie | Vegan, keto, low carb, gluten-free |
| Kirkland Signature Mixed Nut B | — | — |
| All In Mixed Nut and Seed Butt | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Nutbutter Sampler For Waffles
For waffles, I’d choose by flavor first, then check texture, sweetness, and allergens. The four products cover different roles rather than four versions of the same spread: one sweet peanut butter sampler, one walnut assortment, and two mixed nut-and-seed blends.
Match the flavor to the waffle
If you want the spread to provide most of the sweetness, Nutty Novelties is the clearest fit: chocolate, butterscotch, cinnamon, and honey roasted offer recognizable sweet directions. Crazy Go Nuts is a more restrained alternative with maple and oatmeal-cookie flavors alongside sea-salt plain walnut butter. The Kirkland and All In blends have no sweet flavor lineup listed, so they make more sense when fruit, syrup, or another topping supplies that part of the meal. A savory spread can be a good contrast, but it should be a deliberate choice rather than an assumed substitute for a sweet topping.
Decide how much crunch you want
Nutty Novelties and All In are explicitly crunchy, which means they add texture to a soft waffle. That can be a plus if you like a substantial bite; it may be a drawback if you want a smooth layer that spreads evenly into waffle pockets. Crazy Go Nuts and Kirkland do not have a texture specified in the supplied details, so I would not assume they are smooth or crunchy. If texture is a deciding factor, verify the product details before ordering rather than relying on the flavor name or ingredient list.
Read dietary claims in context
Crazy Go Nuts lists 2 net carbs per serving and describes its assortment as vegan, keto, low carb, and gluten-free, but its maple and oatmeal-cookie varieties contain some sugar. Nutty Novelties is described as non-GMO and gluten-free, with little added sugar, but its flavors are sweet. Kirkland lists 7 grams of protein per serving, while All In highlights the absence of certain additives. These are different kinds of information, not directly comparable guarantees. Check the current label for serving details and ingredients if sugar, carbohydrates, protein, or a dietary restriction guides your choice.
Check nut and seed allergies before choosing
These are not interchangeable allergy options. Nutty Novelties is peanut butter; Crazy Go Nuts is walnut butter; Kirkland contains almonds and cashews along with seeds; and All In contains peanuts, almonds, and sesame plus several seeds. A mixed blend can introduce more potential allergens rather than reduce them. I would review the package and manufacturer’s allergen information for the specific product and production facility, particularly when serving waffles to a household or group with food allergies. Do not rely on a flavor description alone to judge allergy safety.
Choose a sampler or an everyday jar
A multi-flavor pack gives you more ways to vary plain waffles, but it also means committing to flavors you may like less. Nutty Novelties offers four distinct peanut butter flavors; Crazy Go Nuts gives three walnut profiles, including a salty plain option. Kirkland and All In are single mixed blends rather than flavor samplers, so they suit buyers who value flexible use across toast, oatmeal, dips, or cooking more than rotation. My ranking favors the samplers for this waffle-focused brief, while the single blends remain sensible choices when everyday versatility matters more than flavor variety.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which option is the best match for sweet waffles?
I’d start with Nutty Novelties because all four jars are sweet-flavored peanut butter: honey roasted, butterscotch, cinnamon, and chocolate. Crazy Go Nuts also has breakfast-friendly maple and oatmeal-cookie flavors, but it includes a plain sea-salt walnut option and the maple and cookie varieties contain some sugar. If you want the topping itself to make a plain waffle taste sweeter, Nutty Novelties is the more direct fit.
Which sampler has the clearest low-carb option?
Crazy Go Nuts lists 2 net carbs per serving and describes its walnut butter as low carb and keto-friendly. The stated figure belongs to the product information and should be checked against the current package, especially since the maple and oatmeal-cookie flavors contain some sugar. I would compare the label for the exact flavor and serving rather than treating the whole three-pack as sugar-free.
Are these spreads smooth enough to use on waffles?
Nutty Novelties and All In are described as crunchy, so expect them to add texture rather than behave like a uniformly smooth spread. The supplied details do not specify the texture of Crazy Go Nuts or Kirkland Signature. If a smooth finish is important, check the package information or product listing before choosing; the ingredient descriptions alone do not establish how easily each one spreads.
Which option is best if I want more than a waffle topping?
Kirkland Signature and All In are both described as versatile beyond waffles. Kirkland is suggested for toast, sandwiches, and dipping fruit or vegetables; All In is suggested for toast, oatmeal, smoothies, dips, and baking. All In has an explicitly crunchy texture and a more savory profile, while Kirkland offers a listed 7 grams of protein per serving. I’d choose between them based on flavor, texture, and ingredients rather than assume either will taste like a sweet spread.
What should I check for allergy concerns?
Check each product’s current ingredient and allergen information before serving. Nutty Novelties contains peanuts, Crazy Go Nuts is walnut butter, Kirkland includes almonds and cashews, and All In contains peanuts, almonds, and sesame along with several seeds. The listed ingredients can help identify direct concerns, but they do not tell you whether a product shares equipment or a facility with other allergens. Contact the manufacturer if that information is needed for a safe decision.
Conclusion
For a sweet waffle topping with the most flavor variety, I’d choose Nutty Novelties, while keeping in mind its crunchy peanut butter base and sweet profile. For buyers who prefer walnut butter and want maple, oatmeal-cookie, and plain sea-salt choices, Crazy Go Nuts is the better fit, with the caveat that two flavors contain some sugar. If your priority is a mixed blend with a stated protein amount and uses beyond waffles, Kirkland Signature makes more sense. Choose All In when you specifically want a crunchy, savory nut-and-seed spread and its peanut, almond, and sesame ingredients suit your household. The right pick comes down to sweetness, texture, and dietary fit—not simply which jar has the longest ingredient list.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
